Followed by the high-profile court order at Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, different copyright holders are facing a roadblock. They are willing to do a settlement between the alleged shareholders which can further help to catch pirates.
Keeping in mind the August order, the federal court is demanding more number of references other than the IP Address.
So, what’s the issue for the court and why the copyright holders need more than IP Address to catch pirates, let’s uncover each information one by one.
The court is willing to Have More Than IP Address To Catch Pirates Story
While this information is not becoming a headline in the mainstream media, the US court is still on the matter of BitTorrent lawsuits. Now, the cases have been filed by a tiny group of copyright holders. In order to prove their claim, the companies make use of IP address as their number one evidence.
The detailing of the IP Address is taken from the swarms of Bitcoins. Further, they are linked with a geographical location using different geolocation tools.
Hence, having information of IP Address in hand, they went ahead to take the matter in the court. They ask the court judge to grant subpoena which will force the Internet providers to give customers personal details. Along with that, even the customer’s account number will come into existence.
Now, if you will keenly observe the process, it is obviously not a new one. While some of the federal judges have said against the accuracy of IP Address. They have said that the IP address is not alone sufficient to prove the worth of copyright holders.
In a recent case, the court ruled off the verdict of a subscriber. They said that an IP address is not enough to prove that the person is an infringer.
A Take on the Verdict
“Because multiple devices and individuals may be able to connect via an IP address, simply identifying the IP subscriber solves only part of the puzzle. A plaintiff must allege something more to create a reasonable inference that a subscriber is also an infringer,” as per the verdict.
Even the court must clarify so as to what they need from the copyright holders to take copyright infringement case forward. In the recent week, different courts have said copyright holders to come up with “something more” than just an IP Address.
Moving ahead, the Malibu Media which is a prolific filter of BitTorrent lawsuits got the privilege to amend the complaint with the help of new details. Previously, the company has filed different complaints still the court has said that the same is not enough.
The company even said that it got different details such as downloading history, residence layout along with the neighbourhood. Sill, nothing went in their favour and the court ruled off the matter.
Read More: Tech Giants Are Warning The Us Government Against ‘Article 13’ Plans
Final Word of Mouth: Court is willing to Have More Than IP Address To Catch Pirates Story
As of now, what is pretty clear is that this is not the very end of copyright trolling. Even today, it is hard for the copyright holders to catch pirate sites and prove the copyright allegations.
However, the court must give some sorts of hints which can let the copyright holders know the process of copyright claiming.
content credit- Torrent Freak
